History:
On November 4, 2021, the local planning agency deemed the proposal not in compliance and therefore not approved. Since then, staff have requested the applicant (via email correspondence) to submit market demand/supply land use feasibility study to determine if the proposed land use changes are feasible. The applicant was also asked to resubmit revised Master Site Plan, Landscaping Plan, Tree Mitigation Plan and Paving Grading and Drainage Plan that addressed the following design elements:
- Provide Low Impact Development (Bio-swales, Rain Gardens, Bio-mats, pervious pavement etc.)
- Provide Buffers to include Native vegetation that creates a habitat of low mid and tall species of plantings.
- Provide Preserve Areas that are contiguous with abutting property.
- Provide Storm-water management techniques that incorporate underground storage, irregular shaped detention, littoral zones and using double ponds to stage and clean runoff.
- Provide Comprehensive Architecture and site design including a streetscape design with variety of unit types with movement to and from the units that provide a sense of place.
- Consult County’s Economic Impact Action Plan, referencing an Innovation district that anchors an ecosystem to support, retain and expand the existing cluster of marine and aerospace sectors by encouraging residential campus form of development. See attachment: Martin County Economic Development Action Plan.
Additionally, the applicant was asked to provide a list of PUD amenities that enhances the project beyond those required under the city's standard zoning regulations.
To date, staff has not received a market demand/supply land use feasibility study, none of the requested revised plans nor a PUD amenity list.
* NOTE: Staff is in receipt of the Power Point presentation that was presented to Commissioners most recently during individual meetings. See attachment: Silverthorn Meeting Pres 12-16-2021 Final
Summary/Request:
The property was annexed into the City via Ordinance 1527-97 with a a Commercial future land use designation and a Commercial Planned Unit Development zoning designation. The applicant is requesting to change the land use from Commercial to Multi-family residential and a rezoning to a Residential Planned unit Development allowing for an 86-unit attached town-home community.
The project is located at the southeast corner of SE Indian Street and SE Commerce Avenue. The Silverthorn RPUD project proposes 86 attached town-home units within 14 buildings with a gross density of 9.05 units per acre.
The proposed land use is appropriate for the area due to the surrounding retail businesses as well as the large commerce center nearby which could provide local jobs for the residents of the proposed town-homes. In addition, with the addition of the AHS at Harbor Grove Apartment project and the Trillium RPUD this area is becoming a horizontally mixed-use area with nearby job and shopping opportunities for local residents.
The developer's architect has submitted contemporary elevations for the Town Home community. Site elements such as a cabana and pool area with connecting sidewalks make for a pedestrian friendly neighborhood. Other amenities include a lake with native plantings at the lake's perimeter. PVC fencing and native landscaping with a minimum width of 25 feet will buffer the project from the surrounding commercial businesses and the FEC Railway. Staff has conditioned that the developer install 'Low Impact Development' techniques that include littoral planting around the proposed retention area and lake to help maintain a healthy habitat.
The applicant is asking to depart from the to the City's Land Development Code which may be offset by providing other aspects of the project which exceed code requirements and or are amenities of value to the community. The departure is as follows:
1. Section 2.07.00.D.4.d - Native vegetation. Excluding wetlands defined by the SFWMD, not less than 25 percent of the total development site shall remain as undeveloped native vegetation area. The required native vegetation area may include open space areas and the landscape buffer between the site and adjacent property; however, other required landscaping such as parking area interior landscaping shall not count towards the native vegetation requirement. The location of the native vegetation area shall be determined using a study of the site with consideration to the value of existing vegetation. The applicant's environmental assessment states that no native upland habitat was observed on the property and the City's environmental consultant confirms that no wetlands or native habitat occur on-site, and no avoidance and minimization efforts regarding wetlands and environmental impacts will be required per Chapter 5 of the City's Land Development Code, however, staff's interpretation of the code Sec 2.07.00D4.d above requires the applicant to provide 25 percent of the site as native vegetation area. The applicant has made efforts to offset the required native vegetation and identified certain trees to remain and trees to be relocated. See Landscape Plan LA-6 Ord 2472-2021 Exhibit D
2. Sec. 6.01.04.B Minimum width. Except as otherwise provided by this Code or b ordinance, where practicable, all sidewalks and bikeways within the city shall be not less than eight feet in width. A 6 feet wide sidewalk exist at both SE Indian Street and SE Commerce Avenue right of ways. Martin County's engineering department has been contacted to determine if an 8 feet wide sidewalk would be allowed in both right of ways.
The developer's traffic engineer has coordinated with Martin County for necessary improvements. An ingress southbound left-turn lane along SE Commerce Avenue will be constructed at the driveway. The applicant will contribute to improvements at the intersection of SE Indian Street & SE Commerce Avenue. Improvements include eliminating the northbound left-turn lane and converting the northbound approach to right-out only.
Recommended Action:
The petitioner shall have the burden of proof at the hearing to show by the greater weight of the evidence that the application is consistent with the city comprehensive plan and complies with all procedural requirements of law.
Conditions may be suggested by the petitioner, the city, or any party, or may be imposed by the board, which are intended to assure consistency and compliance.
Staff has considered the application and evidence provided within the application packet and is of the opinion that maintaining the existing zoning and future land use classifications accomplish a legitimate public purpose significant enough to deny the requested future land use and zoning change.
Therefore, staff recommend denial of the application based on the following:
- Insufficient Public Benefit(s).
- Insufficient implementation of Low Impact Development (Bio-swales, Rain Gardens, Bio-mats, pervious pavement etc).
- Insufficient architectural and site design components which incorporate streetscape design and provide a sense of place.
- Insufficient data in respect of demand and supply of Commercial, Industrial and Residential uses within the City to demonstrate the benefit of the conversion from a 'Commercial Future Land Use' to a 'Multi-Family Future Land Use' designation.
- Insufficient data in respect of demand and supply of Commercial, Industrial and Residential uses within the City to demonstrate the benefit of the conversion from a 'Commercial Planned Unit Development' zoning designation to a 'Residential Planned Unit Development' zoning designation.